Best Bakeries in San Mateo Area 2025 Winners

Home » Best Food and Drink Businesses » California » San Mateo » Best Bakeries

Top Bakeries in the San Mateo Area

The Best of San Mateo contest celebrates the sweet and savory spots locals love most—including the bakeries that fill our mornings, celebrations, and coffee breaks with handmade goodness. Voted by the community for their incredible breads, pastries, cookies, and cakes, these top-rated bakeries are known for fresh ingredients, creative flavors, and customer favorites that keep people coming back. Whether you’re picking up breakfast, ordering a custom cake, or indulging in a seasonal treat, these are the go-to bakeries in San Mateo.

No Records Found

Sorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again.

Google Map Not Loaded

Sorry, unable to load Google Maps API.

  • 2025 Winner:
    Best Bakeries

    Bonjour Bakehouse

    Bonjour Bakehouse in San Mateo is a charming French-inspired bakery specializing in macarons, cookies, scones, and artisan breads. Co-founded by François Bernaudin and Ingrid Sarlandie, the shop uses locally sourced ingredients and eco-friendly packaging. Their "Cookies for a Cause" initiative supports community nonprofits, and their baked goods ship nationwide. Bonjour is praised for its elegant pastries, warm service, and commitment to making every treat memorable and meaningful.

    1007 Howard Ave
    San Mateo, California 94401
  • 2025 Top 5:
    Best Bakeries

    Dianda’s Bakery

    Dianda's Italian American Pastry, a legacy bakery, specializes in traditional Italian baking with a variety of cakes and pastries. Known for their St. Honore cakes and panettone, Dianda's offers handmade products using recipes passed down through generations. A Yelp reviewer notes, "Authentic Italian pastries that remind me of home.” Visit them at 117 De Anza Blvd, San Mateo, CA.

    117 De Anza Blvd
    San Mateo, California 94402
  • 2025 Top 5:
    Best Bakeries

    Antoine’s Cookie Shop

    Antoine's Cookie Shop, established by Antoine Tang in 2016, is a beloved San Mateo bakery known for its freshly baked cookies made from scratch. With a commitment to quality and community, Antoine's offers a variety of flavors that have garnered a loyal customer base. One Yelp reviewer raves, "Best cookies in town! Always fresh and delicious.” Visit their shop at 220 2nd Ave, San Mateo, CA.

    220 2nd Ave
    San Mateo, California 94401
  • 2025 Top 5:
    Best Bakeries

    Backhaus

    Backhaus is a community-focused bakery in San Mateo, offering naturally leavened artisan breads and pastries baked fresh daily. Founded out of a desire for excellent bread and community engagement, Backhaus provides a transparent baking process with large windows into their bakery. Customers appreciate the quality and ambiance, with one stating, "Best bakery in the area!” Located at 32 3rd Ave, San Mateo, CA.

    32 E 3rd Ave
    San Mateo, California 94401
  • 2025 Top 5:
    Best Bakeries

    Sibby’s Cupcakery

    Member: San Mateo Area Chamber of Commerce

    Sibby's Cupcakery, founded by Sibby Ross Thomsen in 2004, is a boutique bake-to-order bakery in San Mateo. Specializing in custom cupcakes, Sibby's mission is to bring joy and happiness to customers through delightful treats. A Yelp reviewer exclaims, "Best cupcakes ever! Always a hit at parties.” Located at 716 S Railroad Ave, San Mateo, CA.

    716 S Railroad Ave
    San Mateo, California 94401

Return to Home Page

Fresh Baked Goods, Artisan Breads & Custom Cakes in San Mateo

San Mateo is home to a wide variety of beloved bakeries—each offering something special for every kind of craving. Whether you’re looking for flaky croissants, rich espresso, rustic loaves, or intricately decorated cakes, these community favorites serve up the very best in baked-from-scratch goodness.

 

🍞

Artisan Breads & Savory Bakes

 

San Mateo’s best bakeries are known for their handcrafted breads and savory selections, including:

 

  • Sourdough, multigrain, ciabatta, rye, and baguettes

  • Focaccia, brioche, and specialty rolls

  • Cheese twists, savory scones, and herb flatbreads

  • Sandwich-ready loaves and bread baskets for gatherings

 

 

🥐

Pastries, Croissants & Morning Favorites

 

Start your day with a treat from the pastry case, featuring:

 

  • Buttery croissants (classic, almond, or chocolate)

  • Danishes, cinnamon rolls, and turnovers

  • Muffins, scones, and coffee cake

  • Quiches and breakfast breads for savory bites

 

 

🍰

Cakes, Cupcakes & Special Occasion Desserts

 

Need something for a birthday, celebration, or just because? These top bakeries are experts in:

 

  • Custom cakes (buttercream, fondant, or naked cake styles)

  • Cupcakes in classic and seasonal flavors

  • Cheesecakes, flourless tortes, and mousse cakes

  • Gender reveal, wedding, and graduation cake designs

 

 

🍪

Cookies, Bars & Sweet Treats

 

For everyday indulgence, you’ll find:

 

  • Fresh-baked chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, and shortbread cookies

  • Brownies, lemon bars, and macarons

  • Gluten-free and vegan options

  • Holiday cookies and seasonal specialties

 

 

☕

Coffee, Espresso & Light Café Fare

 

Many San Mateo bakeries double as cozy cafés, offering:

 

  • Artisan coffee and espresso drinks

  • House-made chai and tea blends

  • Light breakfast and lunch options

  • Indoor and outdoor seating with a welcoming vibe

 

 

🛍️

Grab-and-Go, Catering & Custom Orders

 

The best bakeries also offer:

 

  • Online ordering and holiday pre-orders

  • Office and party platters

  • Wedding tastings and consultations

  • Gift boxes and branded merchandise

 

 

 

Explore the Best Bakeries in the San Mateo Area, as chosen by local residents in the Best of San Mateo contest—and support the talented bakers bringing flavor, comfort, and joy to our community, one loaf or layer at a time.